Posts

Week Eleven - Post Three - TedTalks

One thing I found interesting is that all male power Olympians have the same genome, which just shows you how natural luck is needed to truly become a world-class athlete in that category. No matter how hard someone tried, if they didn't have that gene they will have a much harder time becoming one. My question is there patterns of people in specific jobs or roles having the same genome?

Week Eleven - Post Two - TedTalks

          Human enhancement has existed since the beginning of human evolution due to the survival of the fittest and natural selection. This type of enhacment cannot be compared to the type seen today with genetic engineering directly taking control of this naturally slow process. In all of the male power Olympians, is the same genome. This shows how these humans because of their random chance of their parents passing down that trait to them are able to become world-class athletes, while others never will. If some people naturally have these better genes in them, why would it be unethical for other people to become genetically modified to artificially have these genes? If this enhacment stopped there, there would be no problem, but when one is able to choose to have a baby with enhanced cognitive abilities, and life span it can cause many issues.  Human enhancement has the chance to cause eugenics where society pushes people into having enhanced kids with...

Week Eleven - Post One - TedTalks

https://www.ted.com/talks/juan_enriquez_will_our_kids_be_a_different_species/up-next#t-627970 There have been 29 version of humanity since the beginning of "Humanity" difference between Neanderthal and homo-sapien is 0.004 percent in the genome Small genome changes can lead to a huge impact  Human enhacment already happens naturally in our DNA                                                              All male Olympic power athlete has had the 577r genotype, The ace gene allows humans to breathe in low oxygen situations. Shows how some people have natural advantages, so should those without be allowed to genetical enhance themselves to that same degree.  https://www.ted.com/talks/juan_enriquez_what_will_humans_look_like_in_100_years/up-next#t-933287 Prosthetics now are becoming integrated into the body, internal...

Week Ten - Post Three Independent Research

       One thing I found super interesting this week was how human enhancement could cause such a basic concept like communication to breakdown. No one really realizes how much you communicate with others every day. It is already hard to empathize with a person who is experiencing something that you will never be able to truly understand, so I cannot imagine how hard it would be to empathize with a person who experiences the world in a completely different way. One question I have is if the moral status is partially based on mental capacity, does that mean that those who have higher mental capacity in the current world have a higher moral status already?

Week Ten - Post Two Independent Research

        Human enhancement could radically change the way society functions throughout the entire world, with it causing an imbalance of power to those enhanced with greater moral status, and through the breakdown of communication. Moral status is a topic that is created through many variables, one being mental capacity. As monkeys have lower moral status than humans, and one reason for this is due to monkeys having a lower mental capacity. From this, we can see that mental capacity can play a role in how much status we give to life. The question then becomes, what happens when some enhanced humans gain greater mental capacity, do they at this time gain a higher moral status. This question is one major fear of human enhancement. Without the ethics guiding these possible enhancements, it will only lead to inequality and unjustness. Along with this imbalance of moral status also comes a fear of the breakdown on communication. Humans need socialization and communication...

Week Ten - Post One Independent Research

Image
Human enhancement and supra-personal moral status. Douglas, Thomas Human Enhancement and Communication: On Meaning and Shared Understanding. Authors: Cabrera, Laura Eckert, John In the first graph, there are a number of thresholds of capacity such that, as one crosses each threshold, moral status rises discontinuously, whereas elsewhere it is constant. In the second graph, moral status rises gradually until it reaches some threshold of capacity beyond which it remains constant. Finally, in the third graph, moral status is a binary variable.8 In each case, there is some level of capacity below that possessed by typical adult humans, and beyond which moral status no longer rises. Each of the possibilities depicted in (Fig. 2) is consistent with No Threshold. If Threshold is correct, then enhanced beings could not have greater moral status than ordinary humans: there simply exists no higher moral stratum. Thr...

Week Nine - Post Three Independent Research

    This week really changed my stace from almost an unquestionable support of human enhancements, to one of great worry about the future of humanity. I was truly only looking at the surface benefits of enhancements, like the possibility for stength, and cognitive ability. It just amazed me how many potential negatives I glanced over just for those possible benefits. One question I had is death a neccasary part human life, which gives it meaning? Or can life be lead happily without that fight against the every moving clock of death? Does life at that point still hold the same meaning? (All questions with almost immposible answers)

Week Nine - Post Two Independent Research

       Humans have been enhacing the human body since the very beggining of our speacies, at first just to survie, now pushing it to the absoulute limits for sports and athletics. The quote ‘‘Man is the only creature that refuses to be what he is’’ shows how humans have gone past what we would have been able to do with just our natural bodies, from making clothes, to tools, and to todays computers. Now we are entering the age of Human Enhacment were science has the ability to directly improve our own bodies, through drugs, prostheitics, and genetic engineering. One of the biggest debates over these new technologies is, are they ethically fine, and what society should restrict. Some believe that these new enhacment should be completly unrestricted to not infringe on ones own natural right to control their own body. There are also many that believe that these enhancments need to be restricted to try to combat the social consequences they could have. With no true pract...

Week Nine - Post One Independent Research

Ethics of Human Enhancement: An Executive Summary Fritz Allhoff • Patrick Lin • Jesse Steinberg ‘‘Man is the only creature that refuses to be what he is’’ (Camus 1951 Humans have always been inspired to become more than human, with stories like Gilgamesh, Icarus, Beowulf. Stories about "man" becoming better than our natural ability  We improve our minds through education, disciplined thinking, and meditation. We improve our bodies with a sound diet and physical exercise. Now we are pushing past those natural limits with genetic engineering, implanted technology, and drugs.  Should these enhacements be restricted         - Regulation would hinder personal freedom or autonomy, infringing on some natural or political right to improve our own bodies, minds, and lives as we see fit        -Others advocate strong regulation to protect against unintended effects on society, such as the undesirable creation of a new class of enhanced p...

Week Eight - Post three Euthanasia

         One thing I found interesting was how the Netherlands has become almost an experiment the rest of the world is watching. People are trying to figure out if their stance on euthanasia is truly beneficial to individuals. While everyone agrees on the facts and statistics the Netherlands puts out, people disagree on what side those facts support.  My question is if it is beneficial to a patient to perform euthanasia who asks for it, why is it not beneficial to perform Euthanasia on a patient who can’t ask for it.

Week Eight - Post two Euthanasia

                          Many people today want to die on their own terms, without society or anyone else pushing their ideas onto that person. In bioethics this is where the idea of euthanasia comes into helping people decide on their own last moments. There are three different kinds of euthanasia, v oluntary,  euthanasia requested by a patient capable of making autonomous decisions, n on-voluntary  euthanasia performed on a patient who is not able to autonomously request it, and involuntary euthanasia that goes against a patient’s wishes, or that fails to consult the patient if autonomous. In bioethics the main focus is on voluntary euthanasia, where a doctor or medical professional intentionally ends a patient’s life. The value of life differs greatly depending on who one asks, some hold it as a supreme value that should never be intentionally ended, some hold the idea that life is only valuable when...

Week Eight - Post One Euthanasia

There are different kinds of euthanasia: Voluntary : euthanasia requested by a patient capable of making autonomous decisions. Non-voluntary : euthanasia performed on a patient who is not able to autonomously request it. Involuntary: euthanasia that goes against a patient’s wishes, or that fails to consult the patient if autonomous. Involuntary : euthanasia that goes against a patient's wishes, or that fails to consult the patient if autonomous. Active : when a doctor intentionally ends the life of a patient through an act like giving a lethal injection. Passive : when a doctor does so by an omission like withholding treatment. Physician-Assisted Suicide (also known as Physician-Assisted Death):  when a doctor helps the patient end his or her own life but doesn’t commit the final action. An example of this would be prescribing a lethal dose of medication for the patient to take on his or her own. » THREE CONCEPTIONS OF THE VALUE OF LIFE Vitalism...

Week Seven - Post three End of life

             Before this week I never truly thought about what death is, I only viewed it as not being alive. I realized that I truly did not know the definitions of either of those words. I see myself in the group that sees total brain death as true death. I would be too scared to saw higher brain death, because at that point even if it is impossibility slim, there might be a chance of life again. I also though it is very sad that most people do not die in the way they want to, with most deaths being in hospices, or hospitals, surrounded by nurses and doctors who view death as failure. One question I have is life that is not conscious worth fighting for, and is it morally okay not to try to keep that life going. 

Week Seven - Post Two End of Life

       Throughout the entire history of medicine doctors have always seen death as the enemy, almost causing a warrior like culture that sees death only has a failure. When one is on their death-bed they most likely do not want to be surrounded by people who view these last moments as a failure. Most people want to die in a familiar place surrounded by family, but this rarely is what happens. There needs to be a major change prompted by bioethics to start to have a better transition from fighting death, to helping the patient pass the way they want to. This also brings up an important matter of defining death itself. There are three groups when dealing with patients that are brain-dead, but still has a functioning body. The first groups believes that that patient is dead, while the second believes they are alive, but should be taken off support, and allowed die. The final group thinks that these patient are not dead, and should be kept on live support for as long a...

Week Seven - Post one End of Life

Maggie Little, Professor of Philosophy,  Director of Kennedy  Ethics Lab Robert Veatch, PhD  Senior Research Scholar,  Professor Emeritus of Medical Ethics    Doctors have a cultural that labels death as the enemy, almost taking a warrior stance against it. This in most cases is not the type of support one on their death bed wants. Their needs to be a change in a better transition from fighting death, to planning how an individual’s death will be. ·        Most people report of wanting to die at home surrounded by family, but this rarely happens in the America. Most people end up dying in hospital room, and many times without family or alone. ·        In a case where a patient has no brain function, there are three categories of thought. ·        The brain-dead patient is dead, it does not matter that his heart is beating ·    ...

Week Six - Post Three Abortion

          As I go throughout leaning more and more about bioethics I realize that my previous views and ideas were very shallow and one sided. My believe on abortion is one of a gradual increase of moral status from the very start of conception to birth. As that life develops on more it goes from just partial moral status to full moral status. With the main shift of moral status when consciousness forms. This can wildly change when birth can present major dangers to the mother. One question I have is there a way to find out when consciousness forms in early human life because that is when I believe abortion becomes morally wrong in most scenarios?

Week Six - Post Two Abortion

      In bioethics on of the controversial and global issue is the ideas for and against abortion. While overall in bioethics there is always grey areas where there is no clear or definitive issue, it is especially true in the debate over abortion. Both extremes of purely prochoice and purely against abortion run into many ethical and moral arguments in bioethics. When dealing with abortion there are two main consideration to examine, one, the early life that is the fetus or embryo, and two, the fact that that early human life is developing inside an independent women. Firstly one has to look at the morale status of the early life and its dignity. Morale status is that a creature has restrictions on killing for one’s own purposes, and those restrictions are based on the nature of that creature. Humans have full morale status, while some argue that animals like dolphins, and elephants have partial morale status. Another argument for protecting early life is that of by ki...

Week Six - post one Abortion

·         There are two fundamental halves of the abortion issue. One is how to think morally about early human life, the human embryo fetus, and the fact that that fetus develops inside a girl or woman. A creature is said to have moral status if there are restrictions on killing it or using it for our own purposes, grounded directly in the nature of that creature. ·       It grounds a near absolute right against being killed. This is called full moral status. ·         Partial moral status is when one thinks about high cognitive function animals like elephants and dolphins, while their moral status is lesser, it is still there ·         1. One of the reasons it would be gravely wrong to kill a person like you is that doing so would deprive you of a very valuable future.2. Killing an embryo or fetus deprives it of a future like yours -- ...

Week Five - Post Three Collaborative reproduction

       One thing I found interesting this week comes from a case where a couple decided to have a child, but to have another women carry it to birth. On the contract that was formed they decided if there were twins, the weaker one would be aborted. In this case there ended up being twins but the woman carrying the children decided it was to risky as it was later in the pregnancy than intended. This caused the parents to back out of the contract leaving the two soon to be babies without a place to go. In the end they court case was only out for deciding where these children would go when they were born. This to me is crazy case that shows how little out legal system knows when dealing with these new issues in parenthood. My question is what would happen if their was a court case when the social, genetic, and gestational parent all claimed a child? Who in the end would get that child, and what would the responsibilities of the other parents be?

Week Five - Post Two Collaborative Reproduction

                One growing problem in today's society is the growth of the definition of parent. With our current medical technology a single child has the possibility of having five or more "parents", the social parents that raise a child, the biological parents who give the gametes, and the gestational parent, the woman who carries the child to birth. All of these different types of parents have different responsibilities and rights when it comes to that child's life. These rights may change based on circumstance and many other factors, so they cannot just be decided by law alone. To truly   decide who has what rights one must look at many different moral, and ethical choices. All of these choices must be seen with knowing what right a person even has to become a parent in the first place. The right to parenthood is not the right to have a child, due to it being necessary for two people being involved to make a child. Both negative an...