Week Ten - Post One Independent Research
Human enhancement and supra-personal moral status.
Douglas, Thomas
Authors:
Cabrera, Laura
Eckert, John
- In
the first graph, there are a number of thresholds of capacity such that,
as one crosses each threshold, moral status rises discontinuously, whereas
elsewhere it is constant. In the second graph, moral status rises gradually
until it reaches some threshold of capacity beyond which it remains
constant. Finally, in the third graph, moral status is a binary variable.8
In each case, there is some level of capacity below that possessed by
typical adult humans, and beyond which moral status no longer rises.
- Each
of the possibilities depicted in (Fig. 2) is consistent with No Threshold.
If Threshold is correct, then enhanced beings could not have greater moral
status than ordinary humans: there simply exists no higher moral stratum.
Threshold thus provides a sturdy bulwark against (1). On the other hand,
No Threshold does not rule out the creation of supra-persons; it is
consistent with (1).
- Moral
Status: The moral status for monkeys is less than that of humans. Why this
is, is not agreed upon, but some say due to greater mental capacity. So
what if a enhanced human has a higher mental capacity?
- Enhanced
humans with higher mental capacity, if they truly have a greater moral
status, than unenhanced humans, then this would create people with
supra-personal moral status.(they are morally worth more)
- There
are drugs today, such as the ones originally used to treat Alzheimer’s,
that can improve the cognitive abilities of those who are healthy.
- With
the creating of those with higher moral status, it would cause harm to
those without these enhancements. It could create a situation where the
enhanced are freely able to extort and abuse those who are not.
- Communication and socialization are a basic, and needed
part of human lives. The absolute majority of humans feel the desire to
belong and to be recognized by others. This is just a basic trait as
humans are social animals.
- Humanity evolved in social groups that were small, only
50-200 people in a group. This causes emotional connection to drop for
those who we are unable to connect with.
- For communication to be good, people need to share the
same lifeworld
Lifeworld is through a set of shared values, abilities,
beliefs, knowledge, perceptions, and other social and psychological
factors that current humans build up meaning about the world and
themselves and create and maintain meaningful social relationships.
- Human enhancement has the ability to change this
lifeworld by completely changing some of these variables. Humans can not
relate to bats due to the lifeworld’s being completely different
- This could cause lacking sense of community of those of
enhanced vs unenhanced, leading to the lack of empathy between these two
now different groups.
- Human Enhacment could cause a complete colapse of communication as we see it now, causing massive social problems.
Douglas, Thomas
Eckert, John
Comments
Post a Comment