Week Ten - Post Two Independent Research
Human enhancement could radically change the way society functions throughout the entire world, with it causing an imbalance of power to those enhanced with greater moral status, and through the breakdown of communication. Moral status is a topic that is created through many variables, one being mental capacity. As monkeys have lower moral status than humans, and one reason for this is due to monkeys having a lower mental capacity. From this, we can see that mental capacity can play a role in how much status we give to life. The question then becomes, what happens when some enhanced humans gain greater mental capacity, do they at this time gain a higher moral status. This question is one major fear of human enhancement. Without the ethics guiding these possible enhancements, it will only lead to inequality and unjustness. Along with this imbalance of moral status also comes a fear of the breakdown on communication. Humans need socialization and communication to develop properly, but human enhancement could cause some of this to become much more difficult. With those who are enhanced now share a different lifeworld. This being those who are enhanced and those who are not to no longer share a common experience of the world, breaking down one of the necessary things for communication to occur. Humans can not relate to bats or dolphins because they experience the world in such a different way, and this problem could be created with human enhancement.
These examples show how human enhancement has the ability to bring great negatives, for every possible positive it also creates. There can never be a test run of human enhancement, that will be able to discern all of the negatives that it would create in the real world. So without adherence to bioethics, human enhacment will bring disastrous consequences.
In your view, how should the use of human enhancements be regulated?
ReplyDelete