Week Seven - Post Two End of Life
Throughout the entire history of medicine doctors have
always seen death as the enemy, almost causing a warrior like culture that sees
death only has a failure. When one is on their death-bed they most likely do
not want to be surrounded by people who view these last moments as a failure.
Most people want to die in a familiar place surrounded by family, but this
rarely is what happens. There needs to be a major change prompted by bioethics
to start to have a better transition from fighting death, to helping the
patient pass the way they want to. This also brings up an important matter of
defining death itself. There are three groups when dealing with patients that
are brain-dead, but still has a functioning body. The first groups believes
that that patient is dead, while the second believes they are alive, but should
be taken off support, and allowed die. The final group thinks that these
patient are not dead, and should be kept on live support for as long as
possible. This final group thinks that it is the duty as physicians to prolong
live, not matter the quality of that life. The debate between comes from the
definition of death. The first group uses four measurements to see if someone
is brain dead, unresponsiveness to stimuli, absence of reflexes, absence of
respiration, and finally a test to see brain activity. If these are all
positive they are seen as dead as the first group sees it. The second group
does not think that we should label death due to those tests. One reason this
is such a hard question is that it is not a question based in science, but one
of social policy. Today in America’s law the view of death is seen when
total brain death occurs, but many pushes for a regulation were a person can
declare what they want their ruling of death to be based on. When ruling on
death one also has to take into account futility. Futility is where the
treatment won’t produce the desired results of the patient, or their families,
for example artificial ventilation bringing back brain activity. All of these
things have to be considered in both social, and scientific lenses to ethically
produce a ruling on death.
The advancement of medical technology also brings many challenges to dealing
with death, and the desiccation with it. Medical technology has changed
societies view on death drastically. Less than a hundred years ago a minor
infection that would easily be dealt with today, would kill huge amounts of
people. With advancing medical technology the futility of many treatments on
those considered lost causes today might be able to easily bring people back.
This raises the question of is it morally okay to let a patient die in the
present, when in a year, or five or even ten years, a treatment could help
them. Those in comas that will never wake might have the possibility of life in
the future so is it ethically right to base the death on today's technology.
One of the hardest part of bioethics is that it is attached to an ever growing
scientific field. Every day the chance that a patient will live increases due
to the advancements in medicine. In bioethics one has to not only make ethical
choices that apply in the present, but also ones that take into account
the future.
I believe death is a bigger issue than is addressed here. Is this from the course or your own research? How does this new learning related to your working thesis?
ReplyDelete