Week Five Post One Collaborative reproduction


  • There are multiple meanings of "parents" in bioethics
  • Social parents are the adults who perform or are expected to perform the duties of parenthood (feeding and clothing a child, changing diapers, educating the child, etc.).
  • Genetic parents are the adults who provide the gametes (sperm and eggs) necessary to create a child.
  • A Gestational parent is the woman who carries a child as it develops from embryo to fetus, and who eventually gives birth to the child. 

  • One major problem that comes along with the multiple people who can claim parenthood over a child, is deciding what responsibilities and rights go along with the different roles. 

  • Is there a right to parenthood, first, it is not the right to be provided with a child. The right to become a parent can’t be the right to “get” a child, since that might require forcing someone else to participate (e.g., by giving up their child), or to turn a child over to people who are clearly unqualified to be parents.
  • Negative Rights: rights against other people, or the government, interfering with your own attempts to become a parent. These rights include, for instance, a right against forced sterilization. These rights are well-recognized (if not always adequately enforced).
  • Positive Right: a right or entitlement to be provided help in becoming a parent. This might include, for instance, a right to have insurance cover fertility treatments. These rights are more hotly debated.


  • Should infertility be seen as a disease, and if so should it be covered by insurance. These are both issues that are both uncertain in today's society. Right now, fertility treatments are restricted to only those with the wealth to pay for them. 

  • Are children born out of gamete donation have a right to know who that genetic parent it, or other half-siblings. Does a gamete donor have any moral obligation to those children. This all raises the question who gets to determine what the relationship will be when the child is not a party in the decision making. 
  • Do children born this way have a right to know the donors medical history along with their identity. While this would definitely help the child, it might infringe apon the donors wishes. 

  • The 18th century philosopher, Immanuel Kant, drew a distinction between two types of value, price and dignity. 
  • Price is just what it sounds like, value determined by the marketplace.
  • to have dignity is to have unconditional value, value that is independent of anyone else's ideas or opinions. Dignity also implies in-commensurable value, meaning that its worth cannot be measured or compared to the worth of anything else.
  • This comes into play when we look at what is being sold in fertility medicine. It is morally wrong to treat a person as if they had a price, so is it wrong to buy and sell sperm and eggs. Or selling your blood, and plasma, is that morally right. 


  • The globalization on parenthood brings many benefits and negatives. While it does allow for more and more people to have children, it also causes many cases of possible exploitation. Does the Indian surrogacy industry exploit these women. It is very hard for those involved to make sure that they are not being exploited. 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week Eight - Post two Euthanasia

Week Four - Post Three Enhancements

Week Nine - Post One Independent Research