Week Three - Post Two Disabilities and Reproductio
When one looks at reproductive autonomy it is
intertwined at its base with disability. To look at how it they are intertwined
one must know the basic idea of disability. There are two main models that are very
different when dealing with disabilities. One the medical model is seen as what
can the field of medicine to do to fix or manage one’s body that has something
wrong with it. The second model is the societal model and it takes into account
how medicine can change one’s body, but also how we can change the environment
to best support the “disabled”. One interesting case two look set the
differences between these two models is Down syndrome. With are current medical
technology just fixing Down syndrome is beyond are ability. Doctors have
accepted that the current best thing to do to support those with Down syndrome
is to change their environment. By doing this the average life span and quality
of life for those with Down syndrome. This shows how looking at how ones fit
with their environment can be a better indicator of disability. All of this
ties back to reproductive autonomy and the ethics of prenatal testing. In the
current society the normal thing to do is test fetus for many different types
of disabilities and illnesses, but what does one do when one of those test come
back positive. There are many arguments against this testing, one is that by
testing, and therefore aborting if the fetus has that disability, demeans those
how are living with it. There are many more arguments for and against this but
one idea that is very important is the paradox of harm. The paradox of harm
states that it is impossible to harm something by bringing it into existence.
So if existence is better than nonexistence then no matter what you should not
abort that fetus. All of these things are still debated today in bioethics with
good arguments for both sides.
Reproductive antimony cannot truly be understood without first
understanding disabilities. Without understanding disability one could not make
the correct morale choice when looking at a fetus with a disability. The
correct moral choice for deciding either to have a child that will be disabled
or to abort it is one that debated fiercely. These choices are also change for
very different circumstances. Without truly looking at bioethics some of these
choices seem obvious, but they are truly complex. Bioethics is necessary to
make the best choice for the to do when one is disabled or know an if the child
will be.
"The paradox of harm states that it is impossible to harm something by bringing it into existence. So if existence is better than non existence then no matter what you should not abort that fetus." Was this a quote from the course or your own thoughts? Where did the paradox of harm come from?
ReplyDeleteThe paradox of harm itself was something that my course went int, but it can be used to argue for many different positions if you look at it through different lenses. The paradox of harm has existed in multiple different fields, until it was used in bioethics. It basically states that someone cannot be harmed just by being born. It is used sometimes as an argument for purposefully having a child that will have a disability, like deafness.
ReplyDelete