Week Three - Post One Disabilities and Reproduction

One model of looking at disability is that it comes from the change in forcable and violent change or loss of ones body like a soldier losing a limb. But is one born without legs disabled because they have always been like that.

Dependency is another way to look at disability. Everyone at some point in their life are severely disabled, when we are born and when we are very old with illness and injury adding to this. We are all dependent on technology and society to provide for us. We only notice speacial forms of dependency.

Normalcy is the concept of having a normal human body which is bipeadal, two arms, etc. or if you look at it from the social model it is the body that works best with it environment 

Medical model of disablility: Something wrong with the body that the medical field and medicine should fix of manage that impairment. 

Society model of diabliltiy: The lack of fit between a body and its environment it is living in.

What would we do to help those with disabilities. When looking at it from medical view you can just change the body but when looking at it from a societal view you can change the body and/or the environment it is in.

Down syndrome is interesting case for these views. If you use the medical approach with today’s technology it does not help as much as the change of environment. We have extended life span for Down syndrome patients just through societal changes.

Reproductive autonomy: we as a society have agreed that people have a very large amount of power over reproduction

What are the morality of prenatal test that sees if the their are problems and what does one do after they find out if their are problems 

Paradox of harm: you cannot harm a being that does not exist. If a baby is going to be born you can’t say your protecting it health by aborting it if it is disabled unless existing is worse than nonexistenting. 

One cannot be said to harm someone by bringing them into existence. This is true even if you choose to create someone who will have a disability, since they otherwise wouldn't have existed at all.The only exception is creating someone whose life is literally worse than non-existence. And of course, the vast majority of people living with a disability have lives that are well worth living
.
The Expressivist Argument: Testing for certain conditions might disrespect or devalue those currently living with such conditions.
Revealing Bad Parenting Attitudes: Routine testing suggests to prospective parents that it is problematic to have an imperfect child, and encourages a culture of extreme parental control (or parental perfectionism) and intolerance of imperfection.
Facilitating Uninformed Decisions: Decisions based on test results are often made with incomplete information or prejudice.
Reinforcing the Medical Model: Routinized testing reinforces that disability is a feature inherent in a body, rather than, as the social model claims, a matter of relational fit. This might lead to a harmful social climate for people with disabilities.
Right to an open future is the argument that parents are obligated to give their child the most possiblilties possible for them in life an d not restrict them.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week Eight - Post two Euthanasia

Week Four - Post Three Enhancements

Week Nine - Post One Independent Research