Week One - Post Two What is Bioethics?
Bioethics is looking at
what is morally right and making ethical decisions when viewing medical research or
patients. Bioethics itself is a relatively new field that was just created in
the nineteen seventies. This field came about due to the unethical way many patients
were being treated before. Doctors and researchers before the nineteen seventies
would go to poor African American and other communities to gather people to do
research on. Most of these people were not told any of the risks involved and
only did it because they needed the money. This was only the start for
bioethics as it quickly expanded on from just unethical experimentation on
people to many more things. One example is that of doctor paternalism, which is
the argument that the doctor knows what’s best for the patient no matter what.
This is the idea changed with the introduction of bioethics to that
of what the patient wants is what matters. Bioethics is a necessary field
that changes with every advancements in biotechnology. Without bioethics
one would have no control over how they are treated or what could be done to
them when sick.
Much of bioethics is how much control does the patient have over their own, or their children's medical decisions. Ideas like self-autonomy, and valid consent are basic things needed for patients to be able to control the treatment. Self-autonomy is one of the hardest things doctors must decide before they do anything else. One example of this is if a Jehovah's Witness member needs a blood transfusion, but they refuse it due to religious reasons. The doctors must decide in that moment whether they are competent. Meaning they do not have any debilitation's to their mental functions and are able to make a stable choice. This forces the doctors into a very hard place legally and morally. On one side they have to respect the wishes of the patient, but also they must try to save their life. This causes two morale rules to challenge each other. In most cases in modern medicine doctors have to go with the patient’s wishes even if they would cause death or serious illness. This goes along with what doctors have to reveal to their patients. While one might want all of the information on what is wrong with them or how long it would take to recover, this is not always the best choice. In this case doctors have now law to support them they have to make these choices on a case by case basis. Bioethics is necessary for doctors to make the best morale and legal decision they can make to insure that their patient’s choice and health are maintained.
All of these ideas lead back to one thing, that being what should doctors or researchers do and what they should not. While this question seems simple it is anything but that in bioethics. Medical professionals have to take into account many different factors. Factors more easily definable that are backed by laws, but many are not such as the morale choices they have to make. Without bioethics doctors and researchers could have unlimited control over what happens to patients even if it is not in their best interests of the patients.
Much of bioethics is how much control does the patient have over their own, or their children's medical decisions. Ideas like self-autonomy, and valid consent are basic things needed for patients to be able to control the treatment. Self-autonomy is one of the hardest things doctors must decide before they do anything else. One example of this is if a Jehovah's Witness member needs a blood transfusion, but they refuse it due to religious reasons. The doctors must decide in that moment whether they are competent. Meaning they do not have any debilitation's to their mental functions and are able to make a stable choice. This forces the doctors into a very hard place legally and morally. On one side they have to respect the wishes of the patient, but also they must try to save their life. This causes two morale rules to challenge each other. In most cases in modern medicine doctors have to go with the patient’s wishes even if they would cause death or serious illness. This goes along with what doctors have to reveal to their patients. While one might want all of the information on what is wrong with them or how long it would take to recover, this is not always the best choice. In this case doctors have now law to support them they have to make these choices on a case by case basis. Bioethics is necessary for doctors to make the best morale and legal decision they can make to insure that their patient’s choice and health are maintained.
All of these ideas lead back to one thing, that being what should doctors or researchers do and what they should not. While this question seems simple it is anything but that in bioethics. Medical professionals have to take into account many different factors. Factors more easily definable that are backed by laws, but many are not such as the morale choices they have to make. Without bioethics doctors and researchers could have unlimited control over what happens to patients even if it is not in their best interests of the patients.
Can you expand on the last paragraph? (Connection to the overall theme/topic)
ReplyDeleteGood job on the edit. Stick with the basic idea of bioethics as your overarching theme until you create your working thesis.
ReplyDelete