Week Four - Post One Enhancements


  • Enhancements vs disabilities 
- Runners with prosthetic legs, such as the "Blade" prosthetic legs on average run 30 to 50 percent faster than a normal human.
- If you get rid of all the other factors besides just the prosthetic run speed, it is in fact an enhancement. So with no trauma or the other massive therapy one has to go through, prosthetics improve on the human body in this way.

  • Two main types of enhancement today, adding machine and prosthetics to the human body and, changing the genetics of humans. 
  • Trans humanist want in bioethics want the human race to be artificially evolved by changing are genome
  • Is it principally okay to change and mess with human nature, and even if it is morally okay, can we do it with all of the possible side effects of it
  • What happens when not everyone receives these enhancements. This could cause a caste system with the enhanced humans on top, preying on the "normal humans". These enhancements might have the ability to radically change political, economical, and social power
  • The Earth has seen when two different versions of "man" homo-sapiens and the neanderthals, lived together on earth. But we do not know what caused the Neanderthals to die out, so would we risk the test with radically enhanced humans. 
  • Enhancements vs Disabilities 
    Runners with the prosthetic blade legs on average run 30 to 50 percent faster than a “normal” human. So if you get rid of all the other problems with prosthetics are those Disabilities or enhancements 


    Is their a moral obligation to improve the human genome or is their one not to so we don’t play god 
    Everyone already uses enhancements drugs to help fight off infections to help repair cells and cognitive enhancement through caffeine. This shows how in principal enhancements aren’t bad 

    The argument is over which enhancements are okay and are morally good. And their actual value if we obtain them, will thinking faster make us happier, will living longer. We have to look at what we are trying to achieve 

    Then we have to look at does the way we find Rhodes improvement matter. Is exercising or taking a pill or genetic enhancement all equally morally the same to improve muscles.


    Three things 
    Epistemic worries: how confident are we that we know and can deal with the risks of enhancements 
    Social justice: would these enhancements be problematic to are culture and separate the haves and have not's 
    Human nature and identity: is their a problem with modifying human nature its self can it destroy the use of self 

    Some people are using drugs originally meant for patients of Alzheimer's and narcolepsy to enhance their cognitive state and stay awake longer, is this morally okay

    One worry is about safety when using off labeled drugs. Off labeled just means using a drug but not for its intended purpose and in some cases without any studies backing up what one is doing 

    What is the actual purpose of medicine. Is it to just treat patients and bring them back to what a normal human is. Many think this is all medicine should be. 

    This begs the question what is a dudes or dysfunction in the human body. 

    Medical disorder: this means you are a normal human being but your body just functions on the low end of the human distribution curve

    Social downsides
    When enhancements go on does that just cause us to see other that used to be normal as now wrong.
    Exploration 
    Pressure to be perfect 

    Whether an given enhancement is a giver cultural, economical, and social context opens up more possibilities than it closes 


    Why should performing enhancing drugs be banned in sports. 
    Should they all be banned some or none at all. Do they give the athlete an unnatural advantage 


    Don’t athletes already have an unnatural advantage high tech equipment, tearing coaches and teams, protein shakes and specially made diets. 

    Is just having natural advantage fair being born with more fast twitch muscles than someone else why is this a point of admiration.

     A lot of these performances enhancements drugs are very dangerous but is deciding for the athlete paternalistic. Some times adding more choice makes us worse off 

    To tell what enhancement are okay you need to find the telos or goal of that sport, what challenges is it testing a person for. Shoes can be worn in track because the goal is for sped not foot sole strength 

    he Status Quo Bias refers to the tendency to prefer things stay the way they are simply because it’s what we’re used to. Applied to debates around enhancement, it refers to a hesitancy or fear to change our capacities using radical enhancements regardless of the evidence of benefit or safety.

    Bio-Conservatives vs Trans-Humanists 
    Bio-Conservatives believe it is immoral to change the human genome 

    Trans-Humanists  is think it’s immoral not to help the future generation 

    Who does the human genome belong to is it a common good for humanity to have to unanimously change it 


Maggie little director of Kennedy Institute of Ethics 
























Comments

  1. Good notes. Do you have any quizzes or discussion questions as a part of your course?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week Eight - Post two Euthanasia

Week Four - Post Three Enhancements

Week Nine - Post One Independent Research